I would ask for no pen loop if I could start over. It's not elasticized, which wouldn't be a big deal because I used smaller pens with clips. But even with my smaller pens, I couldn't use the loop because it's fastened in the middle on the side versus at the top. I ended up cutting the loop out and using an elastic loop glued to my plastic insert cover. I'm a little frustrated that I had to do that, but I still love the planner.